Resources

Donor-Advised Funds: Securing the Tax Deduction vs. Retaining Control

For high-net-worth individuals and successful small business owners, minimizing tax liability while supporting meaningful causes is a primary financial goal. For years, donor-advised funds (DAFs) have served as a go-to vehicle to accomplish both. By contributing appreciated assets, taxpayers secure an immediate deduction, bypass capital gains taxes, and buy themselves time to decide which charities will ultimately receive the distributions.

However, a high-profile legal battle over a $21 million account is spotlighting a crucial nuance that many philanthropists overlook: securing the tax deduction means giving up legal ownership of the money.

The Mechanics Behind the DAF Boom

A donor-advised fund operates as a charitable giving account sponsored by a public charity. The core appeal lies in its flexibility. Donors can contribute cash, stocks, or even real estate, claiming a tax deduction for the year the contribution is made. This makes DAFs exceptionally useful for "bunching" charitable contributions into a single high-income tax year to maximize itemized deductions.

Once the assets are inside the account, they can be invested and grow tax-free. Meanwhile, the donor recommends grants to specific nonprofits over time. It is easy to see why these accounts have become a cornerstone of philanthropic tax planning. As of 2024, DAFs held more than $326 billion in assets nationwide, cementing their status as one of the fastest-growing philanthropic vehicles.

Professionals discussing tax planning and charitable giving strategies

A $21 Million Dispute Over Donor Intent

The fundamental reality of a DAF is right in the name: it is donor-advised, not donor-controlled. When you fund the account, the gift is generally irrevocable. Legal ownership fully transfers to the sponsoring charity, making your future grant recommendations advisory rather than legally binding.

In practice, most sponsoring organizations gladly follow a donor's wishes. But a recent legal dispute is testing the limits of that relationship. The conflict involves a fund managed by WaterStone, a Colorado-based charitable foundation. According to court filings, the successor advisor to the fund—the original donor's son—alleges that the sponsoring charity ceased communication and refused to consider his grant recommendations. WaterStone asserts that its original donor agreement grants the organization complete discretion over all distributions, meaning it has no legal obligation to heed the family's advice.

Protecting Your Multi-Generational Giving Strategy

This case carries significant weight for families building a multi-generational legacy. Many DAF sponsors permit children or grandchildren to step in as successor advisors after the original donor passes away. However, internal policies vary drastically across different organizations.

Some organizations embrace multiple generations of advisors, while others enforce strict limits on who can recommend grants or mandate eventual fund termination. Recent shifts in tax law have driven renewed interest in charitable planning strategies, making this the perfect time to review the fine print of your existing or planned contributions.

Key Questions to Ask Your DAF Sponsor

Before transferring significant wealth to a sponsoring charity, consider asking a few pointed questions:

  • Can successor advisors be named, and how many generations are permitted?
  • Can the fund be transferred to another sponsor in the future if a disagreement occurs?
  • Under what exact circumstances can a grant recommendation be denied?
  • What happens to the remaining assets if no successor advisor is named?

Optimizing Your Charitable Impact With Martinez & Shanken PLLC

Donor-advised funds remain highly effective tools for managing wealth, avoiding capital gains, and supporting the causes you care about. However, maximizing their value requires looking beyond the immediate tax deduction and carefully structuring the account to protect your long-term intent.

At Martinez & Shanken PLLC in Gilbert, AZ, we help small business owners and individuals integrate tax-efficient giving into their broader financial picture. If you are considering establishing a DAF or need to evaluate your current charitable vehicles, contact our CPA team today to schedule a consultation. Let us ensure your philanthropy works for both your legacy and your tax strategy.

Share this article...

NEVER MISS A STORY.

Sign up for our newsletters and get our articles delivered right to your inbox.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .

Social Media

Martinez & Shanken, PLLC

1560 W Warner Rd Suite 200
Gilbert, Arizona 85233
Martinez & Shanken PLLC We love to chat!
Feel free to use Ai Chat or Contact Us
Please fill out the form and our team will get back to you shortly The form was sent successfully